Gay Rights Groups Respond to Court Ruling
The
Advocate, June 27, 2003
A number of prominent national gay rights organizations
were among the first to respond to the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision to
strike down Texas’s sodomy law, effectively eliminating sodomy laws in 12
other states as well. Here is some of what they had to say:
Lambda Legal Defense and Education Fund: “Today the
U.S. Supreme Court closed the door on an era of intolerance and ushered in a
new era of respect and equal treatment for gay Americans,” said Ruth Harlow,
legal director for Lambda and lead counsel on the Texas case. “This historic
civil rights victory recognizes that love, sexuality, and family play the same
role in gay people’s lives as they do for everyone else. This ruling
effectively strikes down the sodomy laws in every state that still has them,
but its impact is even broader. It will be a powerful tool for gay people in
all 50 states where we continue fighting to be treated equally.” Lambda
represented plaintiffs John Lawrence and Tyron Garner, who were arrested in
Lawrence’s Houston home and jailed overnight after officers found the men
engaged in private, consensual sex in 1998.
The Human Rights Campaign: “This is a historic day for
fair-minded Americans everywhere,” said HRC executive director Elizabeth
Birch. “We are elated and gratified that the Supreme Court, in its wisdom,
has seen discriminatory state sodomy laws for what they are—divisive,
mean-spirited laws that were designed to single out and marginalize an entire
group of Americans for unequal treatment.” The 6-3 decision in Lawrence v.
Texas makes clear that gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgendered Americans
have a fundamental right to privacy, she added.
The National Gay and Lesbian Task Force: “We welcome
the decision of the United States Supreme Court striking down the Texas
‘Homosexual Conduct Law’ that criminalized same-sex private, consensual
sexual behavior,” said Matt Foreman, executive director for NGLTF. “While
this is a victory for individual liberties of all Americans, it is
particularly welcome for gay people, who have been singled out for persecution
and discrimination by these laws for decades.... The decision is especially
sweet for the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force. Following the Supreme
Court’s infamous 1986 Bowers v. Hardwick decision (which found that gay and
lesbian people had no constitutionally protected right to engage in intimate
sexual relations), we launched our Privacy Project, the first national
education and advocacy campaign to repeal consensual sodomy laws.”
The Gay and Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation:
“Today’s decision by the U.S. Supreme Court to strike down Texas’s
‘homosexual conduct law’ and overturn its 1986 ruling in Bowers
v. Hardwick marks a turning point in our civil rights movement and a
victory for all Americans,” said Joan M. Garry, executive director for GLAAD.
“Lambda Legal’s historic victory in Lawrence v. Texas establishes as a
matter of law that gay and lesbian people have a fundamental right to loving
relationships free from the threat of invasive intrusion by the state.... In
stating that gay and lesbian people ‘are entitled to respect for their
private lives,’ Justice Kennedy’s majority opinion today affirms our
dignity and humanity in a way we hope others will follow.”
The Log Cabin Republicans: “Today’s historic victory
marks a new chapter for gay and lesbian civil rights in America,” said
Patrick Guerriero, executive director of LCR. “We are one step closer to
realizing fairness and equality for gay and lesbian members of the American
family. Log Cabin and the Liberty Education Forum were proud to offer a
Republican and centrist argument in favor of the overturning of these
un-American laws in our amicus brief.... The enormous importance of this law
being overturned is that it will not only provide protection for the few who
find themselves prosecuted for consensual intimacy but that it also provides
protection for those who face discrimination that has been justified by these
laws.”
The National Stonewall Democrats: “The fight for
equality is increasingly shifting to the courts,” said Dave Noble, executive
director for NSD. “This ruling underscores the need to promote mainstream
judicial nominations, since such life-long appointees will make decisions on
LGBT rights for the next 30 to 40 years.”
The Sevicemembers Legal Defense Network: “Today’s
Supreme Court decision overturning the Texas sodomy statute may also remove a
significant roadblock in repealing the federal sodomy statute and the
military’s ban on lesbian, gay, and bisexual service members,” said SLDN
executive director C. Dixon Osburn. “‘Don’t ask, don’t tell’ is a
statute banning gays in the military if they do not keep their sexual
orientation a secret even from their family. The law is predicated on the
notion that prohibition of ‘homosexual conduct’ is essential to unit
cohesion. The military’s prohibition of homosexual conduct is rooted in the
federal sodomy statute codified as Article 125 of the Uniform Code of Military
Justice (UCMJ). The statute applies to both heterosexual and homosexual
sodomy.... SLDN will look closely at today’s ruling and work with other
legal experts to determine what role it may have in tearing down the walls to
equality in our armed forces.”
The Gay, Lesbian, and Straight Education Network:
“Today’s historic ruling affirms the equality of lesbian, gay, bisexual,
and transgendered people before the law and sends a powerful message to LGBT
youth,” said Kevin Jennings, executive director for GLSEN. “The majority
has affirmed that ‘the state cannot demean [the] existence or control [the]
destiny’ of LGBT people with such discriminatory statutes.... By overturning
these laws, the United States Supreme Court has put legislators and school
administrators on notice that LGBT students and educators are not second-class
citizens and there is no justification for qualified educators being fired or
students feeling unsafe in school.”
The Family Pride Coalition: “Today the Supreme Court
ruled for fairness for all Americans,” said Aimee Gelnaw, executive director
of the Family Pride Coalition. “After years of this antiquated law being
applied with prejudice to gay and lesbian Americans, it can no longer serve as
an unjust barrier to lesbians and gay men maintaining custody of their own
children or becoming foster or adoptive parents.” This year the Family Pride
Coalition was deeply involved in successful efforts to defeat three antigay
foster care and adoption bills in Texas. The sodomy law was used as a
reference point in arguments against allowing lesbian and gay Texans the
opportunity to serve as foster and adoptive parents.
[Home] [News] [Lawrence
v. Texas]
